A WORLD OF HUMAN RIGHTS
  • Home
  • Migration & Trafficking
    • Refugees, Asylum seekers & Migrants
    • Human Trafficking & Slavery
  • Security, Peace & Justice
    • Death Penalty, Arbitrary Detention and Torture
    • International Criminal Justice
    • Rule of Law
    • Humanitarian crises
    • Human Rights Defenders
  • Children's rights
  • Civil Rights & Liberties
  • Economic, social & cultural rights
    • Food & Water
    • Sanitation
    • Adequate housing
    • Health
  • Sexual and reproductive health
  • Discrimination
    • Women, Girls & Gender equality
    • Race and national origin
    • Religion
    • Indigenous People
    • LGBTQ
    • Health & Disability
  • Environment
  • Business & Tax
    • Tax Justice & illicit financial flows
    • Business & Human Rights
  • Take action!
  • Free courses
  • About us
    • About our press review
    • Privacy Policy
  • Bibliography
  • Home
  • Migration & Trafficking
    • Refugees, Asylum seekers & Migrants
    • Human Trafficking & Slavery
  • Security, Peace & Justice
    • Death Penalty, Arbitrary Detention and Torture
    • International Criminal Justice
    • Rule of Law
    • Humanitarian crises
    • Human Rights Defenders
  • Children's rights
  • Civil Rights & Liberties
  • Economic, social & cultural rights
    • Food & Water
    • Sanitation
    • Adequate housing
    • Health
  • Sexual and reproductive health
  • Discrimination
    • Women, Girls & Gender equality
    • Race and national origin
    • Religion
    • Indigenous People
    • LGBTQ
    • Health & Disability
  • Environment
  • Business & Tax
    • Tax Justice & illicit financial flows
    • Business & Human Rights
  • Take action!
  • Free courses
  • About us
    • About our press review
    • Privacy Policy
  • Bibliography
A WORLD OF HUMAN RIGHTS
Picture
A WORLD OF HUMAN RIGHTS IS A PRESS REVIEW DEDICATED TO THE STATE OF HUMAN RIGHTS WORLDWIDE

Argentines Fight Court’s Leniency for Human Rights Crimes

5/15/2017

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Daniel Politi

Worried that the men who committed some of Argentina’s most heinous human rights abuses could be freed from jail years early, hundreds of thousands of protesters took to the country’s streets on Wednesday.

The demonstrations were in response to a Supreme Court ruling this month that reduced the sentence of a man convicted of crimes against humanity during the country’s military dictatorship from 1976 to 1983.

The court’s decision led to a flood of requests for the same leniency from others imprisoned for kidnapping, torture and murder. Activists warned that the ruling could pave the way for the early release of some of the era’s most notorious offenders.

But widespread repudiation of the ruling by the public, culminating in the day of protest, which organizers said had drawn half a million people in Buenos Aires alone, forced an uncharacteristically quick and united response from political leaders here.

After just two days of debate, Argentina’s Congress on Wednesday passed a bill intended to prevent any shortening of prison terms for those sentenced for crimes against humanity. The vote was nearly unanimous, almost unheard-of in the country’s divided political landscape.

Hours before the protests began, President Mauricio Macri also came out against the decision, saying he was “against any tool that favors impunity.” His administration had initially emphasized the need to respect the independence of the courts, but changed tack as opposition mounted, and helped push the bill through Congress. It became law on Friday.

Experts say the developments of the week follow a historical pattern.

“On human rights issues, the political and institutional actions have always come after a demand from society as a whole,” said Gastón Chillier, the executive director of the Center for Legal and Social Studies, a human rights group in Argentina.

While it now appears very unlikely that hundreds of human rights abusers will be leaving prison ahead of schedule, activists said the court’s decision exemplified the way in which Mr. Macri had adopted a less aggressive approach to dealing with one of the darkest chapters in Argentina’s history.

Two of the three justices who signed on to the decision were appointed by Mr. Macri, who took office in 2015, and activists say the ruling fits a pattern of his administration’s tamping down efforts to seek justice for the atrocities carried out during the dictatorship.

Trying those crimes was a centerpiece of the policy of the former presidents Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, who served from 2007 to 2015, and Néstor Kirchner, her husband, who led the country from 2003 to 2007.

The court decision “surprised and angered us, but it isn’t incoherent with the philosophy of the current government,” said Estela Barnes de Carlotto, who leads Grandmothers of the Plaza de Mayo, a group of women searching for the hundreds of newborn babies stolen from their mothers in clandestine detention centers during the dictatorship.

“It took Macri a whole week to say anything,” said Victoria Durán, a demonstrator at the Wednesday protest in Buenos Aires.

As protesters packed the Plaza de Mayo square in Buenos Aires, they sang: “What happened to the Nazis will happen to you. Wherever you go, we will go after you.”

Marta Mamaní, 64, went to the march carrying a photo of her sister Olga Mamaní and her brother-in-law Luis Torres, both killed by the military after they disappeared in June 1976.

“The people who killed my sister can’t be walking the streets,” she said. “This march is a huge victory, but it tastes very bittersweet.”

The man to be freed early by the court’s ruling, Luis Muiña, was convicted of torture and other crimes.

When Gladis Cuervo, 77, heard that the top court had reduced Mr. Muiña’s sentence, “I immediately felt despair, anxiety and a lot of pain,” she said.

Mr. Muiña was a security guard at the Posadas Hospital in Buenos Aires Province who helped set up a clandestine detention center there after the military junta’s takeover. Ms. Cuervo, a nurse at the hospital, testified at Mr. Muiña’s trial that he was one of those who tortured her when she was illegally detained for two months, breaking her sternum in beatings and burning parts of her body.

Mr. Muiña was sentenced in 2011 to 13 years in prison for kidnapping and torturing five people during the dictatorship.

In its 3-to-2 decision, the Supreme Court ruled that Mr. Muiña had the right to benefit from a law, which has since been revoked, that says the time a person spends in prison before a conviction should count double toward the sentencing total. A calculation by a lower court found that meant Mr. Muiña should have been freed in November last year. Mr. Muiña was already out of prison on parole when the ruling was issued.

The law, known as “two for one,” was in effect from 1994 to 2001 and had never before been used in a human rights case.

The attorney general’s office, an independent arm of the government now run by an ally of the previous administration, estimated that 278 people, or 52 percent of those sentenced for human rights crimes who are currently detained, could have seen a reduction in their sentence based on the Supreme Court ruling.

But the government is confident that none of these criminals will have their sentences slashed because of the bill passed by Congress clarifying that the “two for one” law cannot apply to human rights cases.

“We think it’s a law that will be applied immediately, so the ruling won’t have any real impact,” said Germán Garavano, the justice and human rights minister.

On Friday, the Supreme Court said it would gather all the pending appeals in its docket to apply the “two for one” law to crimes against humanity cases, opening the door to a new ruling on the issue as early as next month.

Until that happens, some of the most well-known names from that time of state-sanctioned terror will continue seeking shorter sentences.

The Rev. Christian von Wernich, a former police chaplain convicted in 2007 for his involvement in seven murders and 42 kidnappings, asked a judge to reconsider his life sentence. During his trial, witnesses recounted how Father von Wernich was present at torture sessions and used his position as a priest to extract confessions in what became an emblematic case that illustrated how the Catholic Church often cooperated with the military junta.

When discussing the Macri administration’s stance toward the time of the dictatorship, activists often cite how some officials, including the president, have questioned the number of people who died or disappeared during the era.

While official records estimate that 9,000 people were killed or disappeared, human rights groups say the real number is closer to 30,000. Mr. Macri told a BuzzFeed reporter last year that he had “no idea” what the number was.

“Whether they were 9,000 or 30,000,” he added, “it’s a pointless discussion.”

His government has dismantled human rights departments in several ministries that were helping investigate dictatorship-era crimes, and members of the administration have met with those who back the so-called two demons theory that the state actions were the result of a civil war against armed leftist groups.

That change in attitude has spilled over to the courts, activists say.

“Although the judiciary is relatively independent, it is clearly malleable to the agenda of the government that is in power,” Mr. Chillier, the human rights advocate, said.

Mrs. Kirchner commented on Twitter shortly after the decision. “Argentina has gone back 20 years in terms of human rights,” she wrote. “This ruling would not have happened in the previous government.”

While human rights groups celebrated the quick turn of events as a rare victory in the Macri era, they vowed to stay alert about what could happen next.
​
“This government has never been interested in human rights,” said Nora Cortiñas, 87, a leader of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo Founding Line, a group made up of women whose children were killed during the dictatorship. “We stood up to a dictatorship and are still fighting — why would we stop now?”

Published on the NY Times on May 13, 2017.


0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Picture


    Tweets by aworldofhr

      GET OUR WEEKLY UPDATE HERE

      Every Wednesday. Concise. Impactful. Ad free :) 
    Subscribe to our Weekly Update

    Categories

    All
    Abortion
    Abortion Ban
    Access To Clean Water
    Adolescents
    Afghanistan
    Africa
    African Child Policy Forum
    African Committee Of Experts On The Rights And Welfare Of The Child
    Age Discrimination
    Algeria
    Anti-terror Laws
    Anti-trafficking Laws
    Arbitrary Arrest
    Arbitrary Detention
    Argentina
    Argentine
    Arms Embargo
    Arms Trade
    Art Censorship
    Artificial Intelligence
    Asylum Seekers
    Australia
    Bahrain
    Bangladesh
    Barbuda
    BNP Paribas
    Brazil
    Brexit
    Britain
    British Red Cross
    Burma
    Business And Human Rights
    Cambodia
    Campaign Against The Arms Trade
    Canada
    Censorship
    Chad
    Chemical Weapons
    Child Brides
    Child Labor
    Child Marriage
    Children
    Children's Rights
    Child Safeguarding
    Child Slavery
    Child Soldiers
    China
    Citizenship
    Civil Rights
    Civil War
    Class-action Lawsuit
    Clean Water
    Climate Change
    Collective Intellectual Property
    Collective Land Ownership
    Consent
    CoreCivic
    Corruption
    Crime Against Humanity
    Criminal Justice
    Death Penalty
    Democratic Republic Of Congo
    Deportation
    Detention
    Developing Countries
    Dictatorship
    Digital Surveillance
    Discrimination
    Domestic Violence
    Egypt
    Elections
    Enforced Disappearances
    Environment
    Environmental Laws
    Eritrea
    Ethiopia
    Ethnic Cleansing
    Ethno-nationalism
    E.U.
    European Union
    Extrajudicial Executions
    Family Reunification
    Famine
    Food Security
    Forced Labor
    Forced Migration
    France
    Fraud
    Free
    Freedom Of Expression
    Freedom Of Religion
    Freedom Of Speech
    Free Media
    Free Speech
    Gambia
    Gang
    Gender Equality
    Gender Pay Gap
    Georgia
    Gilgit-Baltistan
    Girls' Rights
    Guantánamo Bay
    Guantánamo Bay
    Guatemala
    Haiti
    Health Care
    Honduras
    Hong Kong
    Horn Of Africa
    Humanitarian Aid
    Humanitarian Crisis
    Human Rights Abuses
    Human Trafficking
    Hun Sen
    Hygiene
    ICE Detainees
    Ill-treatment
    Immigration
    Impunity
    Incarcerated Women
    India
    Indigenous People
    Indigenous Textiles
    Indigenous Women
    Indonesia
    Industrial Pollution
    Inequalities
    Internally Displaced People
    International Family Tracing
    International Justice
    Internet Freedom
    Iran
    Iraq
    Ireland
    Israel
    Japan
    Joseph Kabila
    Journalism
    Journalists
    Juvenile Criminal System
    Kachin
    Kazakhstan
    Land Rights
    Latin America
    Lawyers
    Lebanon
    LGBTQ
    Libya
    Liu Xia
    Liu Xiaobo
    Lybia
    Madagascar
    Malawi
    María De Jesús Patricio Martínez
    Marriage
    Marriage Equality
    Mass Incarceration
    Mass Surveillance
    Mauritania
    Maya Women
    Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders
    Media Freedom
    Menstrual Hygiene
    Mexico
    Microsoft
    Migrants
    Migrant Workers
    Misuse Of Government Funds
    Modern Slavery
    Money Laundering
    Mozambique
    Myanmar
    Nationality
    Nationality Deprivation
    National Service
    Nepal
    New Zealand
    Nicaragua
    Nigeria
    Nobel Peace Prize
    Northern Ireland
    Northern Triangle Of Central America
    Norway
    Nuclear Arms
    Occupation
    Orphanage Tourism
    Pakistan
    Palestine
    Palestinian Refugees
    Papua New Guinea
    Paraguay
    Peaceful Assembly
    People With Albinism
    Philippines
    Poland
    Police Abuse
    Poverty
    Press Freedom
    Press Law
    Prior And Informed Consent
    Prison
    Privacy
    Private Prison Company
    Race Discrimination
    Racism
    Rakhine State
    Rape Videos
    Refugee Quota
    Refugees
    Refused Asylum Seekers
    Right To A Nationality
    Right To Education
    Right To Protest
    Rohingya
    Rule Of Law
    Rwanda
    Rwandan Genocide
    Same-sex Marriage
    Sanitation
    Saudi Arabia
    Scotland
    Seafood Industry
    Segregation
    Self-censorship
    Senegal
    Sexual And Reproductive Rights
    Sexual Violence
    Shi'a Community
    Slavery
    Smuggling
    Social Media
    Social Security
    Solar Energy
    Somalia
    South Asia
    Southern Poverty Law Center
    South Sudan
    Spain
    Special Rapporteur On The Negative Impact Of The Unilateral Coercive Measures On The Enjoyment Of Human Rights
    Special Rapporteur On The Right To Adequate Housing
    Special Rapporteur On The Right To Development
    Special Rapporteur On The Right To Food
    Special Rapporteur On Toxics
    Stateless
    Supply Chains
    Sustainability Development Solutions Network
    Sustainable Development Goals
    Sweden
    Syria
    Syrian Civil War
    Taiwan
    Tanzania
    Thailand
    Thomson Reuters Foundation
    Tobacco
    Torture
    Transitional Justice
    Transparentem
    Travel Ban
    Trinidad & Tobago
    TripAdvisor
    Turkey
    U.A.E.
    Uganda
    U.K
    Unaccompanied Children
    U.N. General Assembly
    U.N.H.C.R.
    U.N. High Commissioner For Human Rights
    U.N. Human Rights Council
    U.N.I.C.E.F.
    United Arab Emirates
    United Nations
    Universal Periodic Review
    Unlawful Detentions
    U.N. Office For The Coordination Of Humanitarian Affairs
    UNPO
    U.N.R.W.A.
    UNSMIL
    U.N. Special Rapporteur On Racism
    U.N. Women
    U.S.
    Venezuela
    Vietnam
    War Cimes
    War Crimes
    WASH
    Welfare System
    Women
    Women's Rights
    Yazidis
    Yemen
    Zimbabwe


    Archives

    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014


    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly